Spare Spoons Kitchen
The classic, done chewy: crisp at the edge, soft and bendy in the middle, with a deep brown-sugar flavor. One bowl and a whisk, no mixer.
Get these into the state the recipe asks for first — the steps that use them won't wait.
What makes them chewy. Melted butter (instead of creamed), mostly dark brown sugar, and one extra yolk. Creaming beats in air and makes a cakier cookie; brown sugar holds moisture; the yolk adds fat and richness without the extra water of a whole egg.
The chips: Ghirardelli 60% Cacao Bittersweet Premium Baking Chips, in the baking aisle of almost any supermarket. They're a little less sweet than semisweet chips, which balances all that brown sugar, and they're slightly bigger, so there's chocolate in every bite. One bag is one batch. For a sweeter, more nostalgic cookie, use Nestlé Toll House Semi-Sweet Morsels (same aisle, same weight).
Rest the dough longer if you can. Half an hour is enough to bake. A day or up to three in the fridge, covered, gives a deeper, toffee-like flavor and a more even golden color, because the flour has time to soak up the liquid. Let very cold dough sit on the counter about ten minutes so it scoops, and add a minute to the bake.
Brown-butter version. Cook the butter in a light-colored pan until it smells nutty and the bits on the bottom turn golden brown, then pour it, bits and all, into the bowl and cool it as in the first step. Browning boils off some water, so start with about a tenth more butter than the list calls for. The cookies taste like toffee.
If they spread too thin, the dough was too warm: chill it longer and keep it in the fridge between pans. If they stay puffy and round, the flour was probably packed into the cup. Weigh it, or spoon it in and level it.
For prettier tops, press a few extra chips onto each ball before baking. As soon as the pan comes out, you can nudge any lopsided cookie round with the rim of a glass.
Keeps three or four days in an airtight tin. A slice of sandwich bread in the tin keeps them soft; swap it when it goes stale.
Want oats in it? The oatmeal raisin cookies have a Half chocolate chips option: thinner and lacier than these.
Nut-free as written. Contains gluten, egg and dairy. If nuts are a real concern, check the chip bag; many are made on shared equipment.
Gluten-free: use Bob's Red Mill 1-to-1 Gluten Free Baking Flour (the blue bag, baking aisle). It's denser than wheat flour, so if you weigh, use about a quarter more by weight than the flour line shows. Chill the dough at least an hour: GF flour needs longer to soak up the liquid, or the cookies come out gritty.
Dairy-free: use Miyoko's European Style Cultured Vegan Butter (refrigerated case, near the regular butter), melted the same way, and Enjoy Life Semi-Sweet Chocolate Morsels (baking aisle or the free-from shelf), which are dairy-free. The egg and yolk stay; this cookie needs them for its chew.