Spare Spoons Kitchen
Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
Baking · Cookies · About 45 minutes

Oatmeal
Raisin Cookies

A crisp, golden edge and a soft, chewy middle. One bowl, melted butter, no mixer and no chilling. My favorite cookie of all time.

~55 min total 12–14 min bake per sheet No chill
Spoon cost
Time ●○○○○ Anytime
Vegetarian
Cookiesamounts scale to match
24
Units

Ingredients

Give them room, and pull them while the middles still look raw. Eight to a pan, no more, so each cookie bakes round with its own crisp edge. Take them out when the edges are deep golden and the centers are pale and puffed. The middles sink and set as they cool, and that's where the chew comes from. Bake them until the centers look done and you get a crisp cookie all the way through.

Before you start

Get these into the state the recipe asks for first — the steps that use them won't wait.

  • Three sheet pans lined with parchment (or one pan, cooled between batches), and the oven heating to 350°F / 175°C — they spread, so only eight fit on a pan. Dough scooped onto a hot pan starts melting before it reaches the oven, and the cookies bake flat and greasy

Method

    Cook's notes

    A crisp edge, a chewy middle. Melted butter and baking soda (no baking powder) let the dough spread just enough to set a crisp, golden edge. Most of the sugar is brown, which keeps the middle soft; white sugar is what makes oatmeal cookies run thin and lacy, so there's only a little of it here. The oats, after their twenty-minute soak, hold on to the butter and give the cookie its body. If yours still bake flatter than you'd like, refrigerate the scooped dough for half an hour before baking. If they come out too puffy, press each mound down a little before it goes in.

    Raisins, cranberries, chocolate, or nothing at all? Choose under Mix-in at the top and the ingredient list changes to match. Dried cranberries are tarter and a little chewier. Half chocolate chips keeps half the raisins and adds chocolate. No add-ins gives a plain buttery oatmeal cookie: the dough makes about twenty instead of twenty-four, and without the fruit they spread a little more, so check them a minute early. For a full chocolate chip cookie, make the chewy chocolate chip cookies instead.

    Warm spice (under Spice) adds nutmeg and a little ground ginger to the cinnamon. It tastes like the holidays without being a gingerbread cookie.

    Plumping the raisins. I don't bother, but I can see the appeal. Cover the raisins with very hot tap water for about ten minutes, drain them, and pat them completely dry on a towel. They come out juicier and softer. Wet raisins leave soggy patches and keep the edges from crisping, so dry them well. For a grown-up version, soak them in warm rum or bourbon instead.

    Use old-fashioned rolled oats. Quick oats are cut finer and make a flatter, pastier cookie with no chew. Steel-cut oats never soften in a cookie.

    No walnuts, no coconut. That's a texture call in this house (see Kitchen Notes). If you love them, fold in a handful of toasted, chopped walnuts with the oats.

    Keeping them crisp. The edges are crispest the day they're baked. In an airtight tin the chewy middles share their moisture and the whole cookie softens a little by day two. Still good, just different. To bring back the crunch, warm them on a pan at 300°F for 3–4 minutes. Baked cookies freeze well for a month.

    For a cookie tin, they sit well beside the ginger molasses cookies and Mexican wedding cakes. Put a sheet of parchment between layers so the edges don't chip.

    Nut-free as written. Contains gluten, egg and dairy. If you use chocolate chips and nuts are a concern, check the bag.

    Easier, if you like

    • Freeze dough balls for later. Scoop them onto a parchment-lined tray, freeze until hard, then bag them. Bake straight from frozen, eight to a pan, adding a minute or two. A warm cookie is never more than about twenty minutes away.
    • Store-bought, if today isn't a baking day: Tate's Bake Shop Oatmeal Raisin Cookies (green bags, the cookie aisle) are buttery and good, but thinner than these and crisp all the way through, without the chewy middle.
    Make it gluten-free or vegan

    Gluten-free: use Bob's Red Mill 1-to-1 Gluten Free Baking Flour (the blue bag, baking aisle) for the flour, and Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Old Fashioned Rolled Oats (same shelf) for the oats. Regular oats are often processed alongside wheat, so they need to say gluten-free. The 1-to-1 blend is denser than wheat flour, so if you weigh, use about a quarter more by weight than the flour line shows.

    Vegan: use Miyoko's European Style Cultured Vegan Butter (refrigerated case, near the regular butter), melted the same way, and replace the egg with a flax egg: a tablespoon of ground flaxseed stirred into three tablespoons of water, left five minutes to thicken (per egg). The cookies spread a touch more and are a bit more fragile, so give them the full five minutes on the pan. For the chocolate version, Enjoy Life Semi-Sweet Chocolate Morsels are dairy-free.